top of page

Hawaiʻi's Big Island: Volcanoes, Unexpected Adventures, and a Few Disappointments

Writer: Kevin and Roxanne
Kevin and Roxanne
2 days ago
14 min read

From an unusual farm stay near Captain Cook to the volcanic landscapes of Kīlauea and the rainy streets of Hilo, our five nights on Hawaiʻi's Big Island brought some memorable experiences—and a few surprises.

Pu'uhonua o Hōnaunau National Historical Park
Pu'uhonua o Hōnaunau National Historical Park

Why Visit the Big Island?

For us, the main reason to visit Hawaiʻi, otherwise known as the Big Island, was to explore Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park. And I was really hoping our timing would be just right to see Kīlauea putting on a spectacular lava show!


On our one-and-done trip to the Hawaiian Islands, we spent most of our time on Kauaʻi (blog post here), with five nights on the Big Island. While Kauaʻi is the oldest of the main Hawaiian Islands, Hawaiʻi is the youngest, and the landscapes couldn't be more different. All the islands were formed by volcanic activity, but Kauaʻi's rugged mountains have been shaped by millions of years of erosion and are covered with lush vegetation. On the Big Island, vast lava fields are a constant reminder that the island is still being formed.


Volcanic landscape along the coast at Volcanoes National Park
Volcanic landscape along the coast at Volcanoes National Park

Driving across the island, particularly toward Maunakea and along the southern coast, there are stretches where the landscape is almost entirely black lava rock, with little vegetation. It's fascinating, although not necessarily what comes to mind when you imagine a tropical Hawaiian vacation.


View from our hotel in Hilo
View from our hotel in Hilo

Where to Stay on the Big Island?

We flew in and out of Hilo, renting a car at the airport and immediately driving across the island toward Kona. We spent two nights near Captain Cook, south of Kona, then traveled along the southern coast to visit Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park before spending our final three nights in Hilo.


The Big Island really is BIG, with considerable driving distances between major destinations. Our original plan made sense geographically, allowing us to explore the western and eastern sides without having to backtrack too much.


Unfortunately, the weather didn't cooperate. A tropical storm had recently passed near the islands, and we experienced flash flood warnings and some significant afternoon rain. We kept a close eye on the forecasts and adjusted our activities accordingly, but the weather affected what we could do—and perhaps our impressions of the places we stayed.

In hindsight, three nights in Hilo was about two nights too many. More on that later.



Maunakea: A Mountain Taller Than Everest?

Driving from Hilo toward Kona, we took the Daniel K. Inouye Highway, also known as Saddle Road, which climbs gradually across the island between two enormous volcanoes, Mauna Kea and Mauna Loa.


Maunakea is often described as the tallest mountain in the world, which sounds odd when you know Mount Everest holds that title. But if measured from its underwater base to its summit, Maunakea rises approximately 33,500 feet, with much of the mountain submerged beneath the Pacific Ocean.


We turned off the highway and drove up to the Onizuka Center for International Astronomy Visitor Information Station, located at 9,200 feet above sea level. We took a short hike up to a nearby plateau for views of the surrounding landscape. Even at this elevation, it was noticeably chilly—a reminder that Hawaiʻi isn't always hot and tropical!



The summit is nearly 13,800 feet above sea level and is home to some of the world's most important astronomical observatories. The combination of high elevation, generally clear skies, and relatively little atmospheric interference makes it an exceptional place for studying the universe.


Visitors can continue beyond the visitor center toward the summit, but a four-wheel-drive vehicle is required, along with appropriate precautions for the altitude and road conditions. Our rental car wasn't suitable, so the visitor center was as far as we went.


As we were leaving, several tour vans were arriving. Summit and sunset tours are popular excursions from both Kona and Hilo. A guided tour can be a good alternative if you don't have an appropriate vehicle or aren't comfortable making the descent in the dark.


Our advice: Maunakea is worth considering even if you don't drive to the summit. The visitor center provides an opportunity to experience a very different Hawaiian landscape, but bring warm clothing and pay attention to the effects of altitude.


Tiny House Airbnb
Tiny House Airbnb

Two Nights Near Captain Cook: Glamping with Frogs and Feral Pigs

Our Unique Tiny-House Airbnb


We didn't spend much time in Kona itself, instead choosing an Airbnb on a farm near Captain Cook, south of town.


This was certainly one of our more unusual accommodations. The tiny structure was only about 10 feet wide, with screens rather than windows. The first floor contained a small sitting area, refrigerator, and bathroom, while a ladder led up to the sleeping loft, which was also enclosed primarily by screens. Outside, we had a grill, outdoor sink, and firepit.


I'd describe it as glamping rather than traditional lodging. We were very much immersed in nature, including all the sights and sounds that came with it.


The biggest surprise was the coqui frogs. These tiny frogs, typically only an inch or two long, produce an astonishingly loud call, especially when there are dozens—or hundreds—calling at once. They "sang" until about midnight before finally taking a break. Who knew something so small could make so much noise?


We also had a collection of feral pigs wandering around the property, occasionally waiting for guava fruit to fall from the trees and sometimes getting into squabbles with each other. Add in the cats, roosters, and the farm's unusual "pig disc golf," and this was hardly your typical tropical resort.


We enjoyed the experience, although two nights was just about the right amount.


Captain Cook Monument Trail
Captain Cook Monument Trail

The Captain Cook Monument Trail: So Close, Yet So Far!

One of the activities I was really looking forward to was hiking down to Kealakekua Bay, snorkeling in the clear water near the Captain Cook Monument, and then hiking back out.

The trail is approximately four miles round-trip, with about 1,300 feet of elevation change. It's considered difficult, largely because the return hike is entirely uphill, with limited shade and plenty of heat.


Our Airbnb was only about half a mile from the trailhead, and our host suggested walking there rather than driving. In hindsight, I disagree! That additional uphill walk wasn't particularly enjoyable, especially knowing we had a strenuous hike ahead.


We packed our snorkeling gear and headed down the trail, looking forward to the reward of a swim before making the climb back.


We were nearly at the bottom when disaster struck.



I realized that the sole of my old Keen sandal was coming apart, with the back half flapping loosely as I walked. URGH! I hadn't thought twice about bringing these older sandals to Hawaiʻi, but the heat and rugged volcanic rocks weren't exactly gentle on aging footwear.

I worried that the sole would detach completely, leaving me stranded without a functional shoe—or that the other shoe would have the same issue. We reluctantly decided to turn around, even though we were only about 0.2 miles from our destination.


Fortunately, I had two rubber bands that we managed to wrap around the sandal to hold the sole in place. They got me back up the trail, and we later found Shoe Goo at a local hardware store for a more permanent repair.


The climb back was hard enough, but what made it especially disappointing was missing the snorkeling and chance to relax at the bottom.


Lesson learned: Don't assume older hiking shoes are fine just because they look okay. Check the soles and adhesives before heading out on a remote trail. We'll be adding this one to our lessons-learned blog!


Carvings at Pu'uhonua o Hōnaunau National Historical Park
Carvings at Pu'uhonua o Hōnaunau National Historical Park

Puʻuhonua o Hōnaunau National Historical Park — 5/5

This was one of our favorite stops on the Big Island. Not only is the setting beautiful, but it's also a place with significant cultural and historical importance.


In ancient Hawaiʻi, the site served as a place of refuge for people who had violated the kapu system of sacred laws, as well as others seeking protection. The nearby royal grounds included important residential and ceremonial sites.


Today, the National Park Service manages the historic site, which includes reconstructed structures, traditional carved figures, and a scenic coastal setting. Our America the Beautiful National Parks pass covered admission.


Gorgeous scenery at Pu'uhonua o Hōnaunau National Historic Park

We'd originally hoped to hike part of the 1871 Trail, but after using up so much energy on the Captain Cook Monument Trail, we opted for the shorter walk through the main historic sites along the bay.


Even without the longer hike, we found this to be a fascinating and worthwhile stop.


Food and Drinks Around Captain Cook

Place

Rox's rating

Our take

Shaka Tacoz

5/5

One of our favorite casual food stops in the area.

Black Rock Pizza

4/5

A good option for a casual meal.

Kealia Ranch Store — Shave Ice

4/5

A refreshing stop for shave ice and colorful geckos!

Punaluʻu Black Sand Beach
Punaluʻu Black Sand Beach

From Kona to Hilo: Black Sand Beaches and Volcanoes

Rather than driving directly to Hilo, we followed the southern route around the island, stopping at Punaluʻu Black Sand Beach and Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park along the way.

We had originally planned to dedicate a separate day to the national park, but the forecast for the following days looked increasingly wet. We decided to visit while the weather was relatively cooperative, even if it meant fitting more into a single day.

This turned out to be a good decision.


Green Sea Turtle resting at the Punalu'u Beach
Green Sea Turtle resting at the Punalu'u Beach

Punaluʻu Black Sand Beach — Worth a Quick Stop

Punaluʻu is one of the Big Island's well-known black sand beaches, formed from volcanic material. It's easily accessible and requires only a short detour from the highway.

We stopped for about ten minutes, enough to admire the unusual black sand and a green sea turtle resting on the beach.


It's a worthwhile stop if you're already traveling along the southern coast, although I wouldn't necessarily make a special trip just for this beach.


Mt. Kilauea was smoking but lava wasn't flowing.
Mt. Kilauea was smoking but lava wasn't flowing.

Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park: Waiting for Kīlauea to Erupt

This was the attraction I'd most anticipated on the Big Island. I've seen countless photos and videos of Kīlauea erupting, with fountains of glowing lava shooting hundreds of feet into the air. How amazing would it be to see that in person?


Unfortunately, volcanoes don't operate on a tourist's schedule.



Kīlauea: An Active Volcano, but Not Always Erupting

Kīlauea is one of the world's most active volcanoes, but that doesn't mean it's continuously spewing lava. Since December 2024, the volcano has been experiencing a series of eruptions that the U.S. Geological Survey calls "episodes."


During an episode, spectacular fountains of molten lava can shoot hundreds of feet into the air. These events often last just a few hours before the volcano quiets down again, sometimes for weeks.


Unfortunately, our timing wasn't great. Episode 55 occurred on October 17, eight days before we arrived on the Big Island, and Episode 56 didn't happen until November 5, five days after we left. We managed to visit right between two spectacular eruptions!


The USGS monitors the volcano closely and publishes forecasts based on seismic activity and changes in ground elevation as magma accumulates below the surface. These forecasts can provide a general window for the next episode, but predicting the exact timing remains difficult.


Our advice: If seeing active lava is a priority, follow the USGS Hawaiian Volcano Observatory updates before and during your trip. But don't count on Kīlauea performing on demand!



What We Saw at Volcanoes National Park

Although we didn't get to see the lava fountains, we still enjoyed exploring the volcanic landscape and learning more about how these islands continue to evolve.


No lava flow, so we dressed in lava-like colors to make up for it!
No lava flow, so we dressed in lava-like colors to make up for it!

Kīlauea Iki Overlook

This viewpoint provides a dramatic perspective of Kīlauea Iki crater, where a 1959 eruption created a huge lava lake. The hardened lava floor and surrounding forest are an impressive contrast.

Entering the Lava Tube
Entering the Lava Tube

Nāhuku (Thurston Lava Tube)

Walking through a lava tube is a fascinating experience. These tunnels form when the surface of flowing lava hardens while molten lava continues moving underneath. Eventually, the lava drains away, leaving a hollow passage.


Driving on the Chain of Craters Road

Chain of Craters Road

This scenic road descends from the volcanic summit toward the coast, passing through landscapes shaped by eruptions from different periods. It's an opportunity to see just how dramatically lava flows can alter the terrain.


The Sea Arch had fallen about a month before our visit.  The coastline was still beautiful and worth a visit.
The Sea Arch had fallen about a month before our visit. The coastline was still beautiful and worth a visit.

The Former Hōlei Sea Arch

At the end of Chain of Craters Road, the coastline offers dramatic views of lava cliffs meeting the Pacific Ocean. The well-known Hōlei Sea Arch had collapsed just weeks before our visit, another example of how quickly these volcanic landscapes can change.



Our Impressions of Volcanoes National Park

I found the park interesting and am glad we visited, although I'll admit I expected a little more. Perhaps the anticipation of seeing active lava had raised my expectations. Without an eruption underway, some of the viewpoints were less dramatic than I'd imagined, and I thought there would be more hiking opportunities or places to explore.


Our decision to visit while driving from Kona to Hilo also limited how much time we had. With better weather and another full day, we might have explored more of the park's trails.

Still, the geology is fascinating, and the experience added considerable context to the eruption videos I'd been following on Instagram.


Reeds Bay in HIlo
Reeds Bay in HIlo

Hilo: Three Nights Was Too Long

Hilo was our final base on the Big Island, and unfortunately, it was a bit disappointing.


I want to be fair. We arrived on the heels of a tropical storm, and the rain undoubtedly affected our experience. It's difficult to appreciate a city when the weather keeps you indoors or forces you to change your plans.



But even allowing for the weather, Hilo wasn't quite what we'd expected. I do a lot of research when planning where to stay, and most of what I'd read emphasized Hilo's lush tropical setting, historic character, and convenient location near Volcanoes National Park. While all of that is true, we found a city that felt quite different from the picture we'd imagined.


Hilo has clearly experienced its share of challenges. We noticed aging and abandoned buildings, and later learned more about the city's history, including devastating tsunamis and the decline of the sugar industry. That background gave us a better understanding of the community and why some of the 1950's ocean-front hotel properties had been abandoned. It reminded us that there's often much more to a place than what appears in travel guides.



In hindsight, I think our disappointment had as much to do with our expectations, the persistent rain, and our choice to spend three nights here as it did with Hilo itself.



Our Hotel: SCP Hilo — Not What We Expected

We booked three nights at SCP Hilo, which markets itself as a boutique hotel. With excellent online reviews, nightly rates approaching $350, and an additional "resort fee," we expected a nice place. To be fair, we used Chase credit card points for this stay, so that's not what we actually paid—but the advertised rate certainly raised our expectations.



When we arrived, we actually drove around the property twice, not quite believing this was the hotel we'd booked. The exterior looked dated and poorly maintained, nothing like the impression we'd gotten from the marketing photos.


Although our room had updated flooring and furnishings, many other elements—including the walls, ceilings, electrical work, and exterior corridors—were in poor condition. The renovations were the bare minimal to achieve good photos, with plenty of details left unfinished or overlooked.


We've stayed in numerous modest hotels and Airbnbs and have no problem with basic accommodations when the price reflects that. But in this case, the premium rate, resort fee, and boutique hotel marketing created expectations that simply weren't met.


Unfortunately, the rainy weather kept us in our room more than anticipated, giving us plenty of time to notice all those odd details and renovation shortcuts! On a positive note, the staff was friendly and welcoming.


Lesson learned--- do a google street view to understand actual conditions around lodging property.


Monkey Pod Tree in Lili'uokalani Gardens
Monkey Pod Tree in Lili'uokalani Gardens

Exploring Hilo

Despite the disappointment with the city and hotel, there are some interesting places to visit and explore in Hilo.


Japanese public garden:  Lili'uokalani Gardens
Japanese public garden: Lili'uokalani Gardens

Liliʻuokalani Gardens — A Peaceful Place

Our first stop was Liliʻuokalani Gardens, a Japanese-style public garden along Hilo Bay. The setting was peaceful, with impressive banyan and monkeypod trees and pleasant paths for walking.


The gardens weren't as meticulously maintained as some Japanese gardens we've visited, but given that this was a public place without an admission fee, we didn't have especially high expectations. It was a nice place to stretch our legs and enjoy the surroundings.


Banyan Tree
Banyan Tree

Banyan Drive

Near the gardens is Banyan Drive, a street lined with enormous banyan trees. On closer inspection, we noticed plaques identifying the people who planted them, including notable visitors such as Babe Ruth.


The trees themselves are quite impressive, and the plaques add an interesting bit of local history.



Hilo Attractions, Food, and Drinks

Place

Our rating

Our take

Mokupāpapa Discovery Center

4/5

An interesting educational stop focused on the remote Northwestern Hawaiian Islands and their marine environment.

Lyman Museum and Mission House

4/5

A worthwhile place to learn about Hawaiʻi's natural and cultural history.

Ola Brew

4/5

One of our better food and drink stops in Hilo.

Puka Puka Kitchen

4/5

A casual dining stop we enjoyed.

Hilo Farmers Market

3/5

Worth browsing for local produce. Wednesdays and Saturdays feature an expanded market with more vendors, including crafts and souvenirs.

Pacific Tsunami Museum

3/5

Provides context for the devastating tsunamis that have shaped Hilo's history.

Café Pesto

3/5

A dining option in downtown Hilo.

Big Island Candies

2/5

Join the tour buses from cruise ships to get a small candy and cookie sample. Meh.

Reeds Bay Beach Park

3/5

A quick stop along the Hilo waterfront.

Laupahoehoe Point Beach
Laupahoehoe Point Beach

Exploring the Hāmākua Coast North of Hilo

We also spent time driving north of Hilo along the lush Hāmākua Coast, stopping at waterfalls, coastal viewpoints, and small communities.

Place

Our rating

Our take

ʻOnomea Bay Trail

3/5

A short walk through tropical vegetation with coastal views.

ʻAkaka Falls State Park

3/5

A scenic waterfall surrounded by lush vegetation, although not quite as memorable for us as we'd expected.

Laupāhoehoe Beach Park

3/5

A dramatic coastal stop with a history connected to the 1946 tsunami.

Tex Drive In

5/5

One of our favorite stops along the Hāmākua Coast, especially for its famous malasadas.

The weather certainly colored our impression of these places, so keep that in mind! We would have liked to have explored the far north shore of the island but heavy rains forced us to turn around and head back to Hilo after we stopped at Tex Drive In.



What We'd Do Differently on the Big Island

In hindsight, we wouldn't have used Hilo as a base.


The city is conveniently located for exploring the eastern side of the island and Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park, but we didn't find enough that appealed to us to justify such a long stay. And the rainy weather made our lodging choice particularly unfortunate.


If we were planning this trip again, I'd consider a shorter stay on the Big Island—perhaps three or four nights rather than five—and spend more time on the Kona-side or near Volcanoes National Park. We also would have flown into and out of Kona in lieu of Hilo.


I'd also give more thought to staying in Volcano Village for a night. Being closer to the park would offer more flexibility to explore the trails and potentially return if Kīlauea became active. The issue with this location is the potential for "vog" or volcanic smog.


Our time on the Big Island wasn't a complete disappointment. We loved the unusual farm stay near Captain Cook, found Puʻuhonua o Hōnaunau fascinating, enjoyed the volcanic scenery, and had some memorable meals and experiences.



Rox vs. Kevin: Our Top Five Big Island Experiences

We don't always agree on what makes a great travel experience, so we'll compare our favorites before making the final rankings.

Rank

Rox's favorites

Kevin's favorites

1

Puʻuhonua o Hōnaunau National Historical Park

Puʻuhonua o Hōnaunau National Historical Park

2

Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park

Unique farm stay near Captain Cook

3

Unique farm stay near Captain Cook

Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park

4

Maunakea Visitor Information Station

Maunakea Visitor Information Station

5

Tex Drive In

Tex Drive In

 

Blue skies can make all the difference!  View from Captain Cook Monument Trail
Blue skies can make all the difference! View from Captain Cook Monument Trail

So, Was the Big Island Worth Visiting?

Yes, although I think we could have experienced much of what interested us in fewer days.


The volcanic landscapes are unlike anything we'd seen elsewhere, and it was fascinating to experience such a young and geologically active island. Even without a lava eruption, Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park was worth visiting.


Would we return? Probably not, although that's mostly because our travel bucket list is so long. If we had another opportunity to visit the Hawaiian Islands, I'd be much more inclined to return to Kauaʻi and also fit in a visit to Honolulu for the Pearl Harbor Museum.


Our biggest takeaway from the Big Island is that where you stay—and how long you stay there—can make a significant difference in how you experience a destination. For us, a few adjustments to the itinerary might have resulted in a much more satisfying trip.


And, of course, a little less rain wouldn't have hurt! We don't mind a few misty rains, but when it's tropical storm weather and they are talking about "monsoon" rains and flash flooding, it can put a damper on plans!



Comments


roxkev.jpg

About Us

Hi. Kevin and Roxanne here. We are a couple of architects that love every bit of travel- from the planning and details, to the actual adventure, to the stories we have experienced and created. 

​

Contact us at: travelneartravelfar2020@gmail.com

​

Location:  Minneapolis, Minnesota

 

Read More

 

Join My Mailing List

Thanks for submitting!

© 2026 Travel Near, Travel Far. All rights reserved.
Original photographs and content may not be reproduced without permission.

  • White Facebook Icon
bottom of page